When it comes to choosing a driver, golfers often look for a blend of distance, forgiveness, and accuracy.
Two standout options from TaylorMade are the M4 and the SIM2 Max drivers. Even though they are each a few years old, they are still seen on the course all the time, because they are top tier drivers regardless of the year.
Both golf clubs have made significant impacts on the market, but they cater to different types of golfers.
In this article, we’ll delve into a detailed comparison of these two drivers, including my personal experience with each, to help you determine which one might be the best fit for your game.
Table of contents
Release and Response to Taylormade M4 & SIM2 Max Drivers
The TaylorMade M4 driver was released in 2018 as part of the M series, which received a lot of acclaim for introducing the world to the revolutionary Twist Face technology to increase forgiveness on mishits. The result; straighter shots.
The SIM2 Max driver, on the other hand, was launched in 2021 and is part of the SIM (Shape In Motion) series, which focused on aerodynamics, advanced materials, and increasing forgiveness on mishits.
When a golf club is more forgiving, the golfer’s bad shots should be closer to their good shots, allowing the golfer to achieve greater consistency.
Twist Face is designed to help enhance shots that are hit on 2 different parts of the club face; high and on the toe and low on the heel. Shots hit on the low heel area tend to curve more to the right with a higher spin rate, while shots hit on the high toe area tend to curve left with a lower spin rate.
To help counteract these two shots, TaylorMade has added more curvature to the clubface than what a normal clubhead would have, in a radical departure in driver design going back over 100 years. However, the hesitation many felt disappeared as soon as professional and amateur golfers alike got their hands on these new drivers.
Design and Technology
Taylormade M4 Driver
Twist Face Technology
The M4 was the first driver to feature TaylorMade’s Twist Face technology, which is designed to reduce side spin and deliver straighter shots on off-center hits. This was TaylorMade’s solution to counteract golfers’ most common misses, more specifically, those resulting from the high toe and low heel impacts.
Hammerhead Slot
The M4 also includes the Hammerhead Slot, which increases the sweet spot and helps maintain ball speed on mishits, contributing to the overall forgiveness of the driver.
Geocoustic Technology
In addition to providing more forgiveness, the Geocoustic sole design works to optimize the sound and feel of the M4 driver when striking the ball. It also creates a larger club face with a significantly larger sweet spot compared to previous generations of Taylormade drivers.
Taylormade SIM2 Max Driver
Forged Ring Construction
The SIM2 Max features a Forged Ring Construction that unites the top, rear, and bottom of the driver, resulting in a more stable and forgiving club head. Forged from light weight, high strength aluminum this aspect unites the rear weight, fully carbon sole, crown, and club face. Also, it just looks great.
Speed Injected Twist Face
Building on the original Twist Face, the SIM2 Max’s Speed Injected Twist Face is calibrated to maximize ball speed across the face, with the corrective face curvature ensuring peak performance even on off-center strikes. This element pushes the SIM2 Max to the threshold of the legal speed limit for golf balls coming off its face.
Split Mass Weighting
Taylormade added some functional design elements to the SIM2 Max Driver. These include a TPS weight on the sole of the SIM2 Max, as well as 16 grams of steel at the rear. What does this mean for you? Enhanced forgiveness and spin properties to help you drive the ball the best you ever have.
Personal Experience & Performance Comparison
During my weekend testing session, I used both the SIM2 Max and the M4 drivers to get a feel for their performance in terms of distance, forgiveness, and dispersion. I used each of the drivers on both Saturday and Sunday to ensure my swing was consistent for both and I did walk away with a favorite, which was supported by the distance and dispersion data.
Distance
The SIM2 Max consistently delivered longer drives for me, with an average increase of about 15-20 yards compared to the M4. This can probably be attributed to the aerodynamic design and advanced materials used in the SIM2 Max, as well as the enhanced forgiveness it offers. Which makes sense, because the SIM2 Max was released 3 years after the Taylormade M4.
The M4 was a little less forgiving, and my mishits were very short and to the right. A persons individual swing definitely plays a role, but over the course of 18 holes I will probably have a few mishits. With the SIM2, that isn’t going to add multiple strokes to those holes.
With the SIM2 Max I averaged around 230 yards, while the average distance for the M4 on clean strikes was around 217 yds. However, the M4 was not nearly as consistent with the mishits and left the ball short of 200 yards multiple times (short and to the right, as seen in the dispersion chart).
Forgiveness
I’ll be honest, both drivers are forgiving. However, possibly due to the fact that I needed more forgiveness because of how I was hitting the ball over the weekend, the SIM2 Max really stood out. The SIM 2 Max has a much larger sweet spot and with that, improved MOI. Meaning that my mis-hits still traveled a good distance and remained on-line.
The M4 was forgiving, but not to the degree of the of the SIM2. Several shots with the M4 would have left me searching in the woods for my ball. For me, the ball seemed to want to go to the right with the M4, which isn’t good if you’re a player already battling a slice. If this sounds like you, the SIM2 Max is what you want! Read no further!!
Dispersion
In terms of dispersion, the SIM2 Max again had the edge. My shot groupings were tighter with the SIM2 Max, indicating better consistency and accuracy compared to the M4.
The Taylormade M4 Driver had a few balls go significantly shorter, as well as a several go around 20 yards off line to the right (with a few going a little further than that).
Aesthetics and Feel
The M4 has a classic look with a predominantly black and silver color scheme, while the SIM2 Max sports a more modern design with blue accents. At address they both look very similar, however the M4 has a little more silver towards the face. Both clubs look great as you are teeing up. It’s a tie for me here.
In terms of feel, the SIM2 Max provided a more solid and satisfying impact sensation, which I preferred over the M4. The ball comes off the face incredibly fast and crisp, which is probably why it is still used by both amateur and professional golfers in 2024.
Price Considerations
As previous generation models, the M4 and SIM2 Max are priced to steal. For golfers on a budget, both Taylormade drivers are excellent options without sacrificing too much in terms of performance. Taylormade released the Stealth, Stealth 2, and Qi10 Drivers in the last couple years following the SIM2 Max, which has led to both of these drivers being around the $250 price point. You cannot find a better driver at a better price, new. Period.
Recommendations
Based on my testing and the features of each driver, here are my recommendations:
•TaylorMade M4 Driver: Ideal for golfers looking for a high-quality driver and aren’t battling a slice. It’s also a great option for those who prefer a classic look and feel in their driver. The neutral colors may be very appealing to some golfers.
•TaylorMade SIM2 Max Driver: Best suited for golfers who prioritize distance and forgiveness and want the latest technology at the best possible price. It’s also a great choice for players seeking a modern, trendy design and a premium feel.
Conclusion
Both the TaylorMade M4 and SIM2 Max drivers offer impressive performance at a truly unbeatable price, but they cater to different preferences and styles of play.
The M4 is a solid choice for golfers looking for a traditional design and in my experience, have no issues with a slice. However, the friend I had with me had no problem hitting the ball straight consistently. It is a great driver for the price.
The SIM2 Max is ideal for those seeking the latest advancements in golf technology and a focus on distance and forgiveness. I will absolutely be using the TaylorMade SIM2 Max for rounds in the future. I cannot recommend the SIM2 Max more highly for beginners, and golfers looking to hit the fairway more consistently.
Ultimately, the best driver for you will depend on you and your specific needs. I always recommend testing out a driver before purchasing but if that isn’t an option, go with the TaylorMade SIM2 Max.
Drew lives in Tennessee and covers the American side of ProjectGolf Magazine.
- TaylorMade SIM2 Max Driver vs M4 Driver: Worth it in 2024? - April 15, 2024
- 3 Ways to Win the Mental Game with the Bridgestone Mindset Golf Ball - March 29, 2024
- TaylorMade SIM Max & SIM2 Max Drivers: Are they Still Relevant in 2024? - March 9, 2024
